The Government is minded to merge West Oxfordshire into a Northern Oxfordshire Council from April 2029. The district council says it is disappointed.

West Oxfordshire District Council is back on course to be abolished, a year later than first planned. The Government said on Thursday 29 October that it is “minded to” replace the seven councils in Oxfordshire and West Berkshire with three unitary councils, and every part of West Oxfordshire, Witney included, would go into a new Northern Oxfordshire Council with most of Cherwell.

Elections to the new councils would be held in May 2028 and they would take over on 1 April 2029, according to the minister’s letter to Oxfordshire’s council leaders. It is not final. Councils and “other interested parties” now have about three weeks to make representations before the Secretary of State decides.

The district council, which argued for a different model, is not happy.

“We are disappointed”

Cllr Andy Graham, the Leader of West Oxfordshire District Council, responded in a statement issued the same day.

Cllr Andy Graham standing in front of the West Oxfordshire District Council sign at the Woodgreen offices in Witney
Cllr Andy Graham, Leader of West Oxfordshire District Council, outside the council's Woodgreen offices in Witney. Photo: supplied by West Oxfordshire District Council

“We are disappointed with the Government’s decision,” he said. “We remain concerned that the relatively small size of the proposed new unitary councils will make it economically challenging to deliver the full range of services residents rely on.

“However, today’s announcement provides greater certainty about the future of local government in Oxfordshire and West Berkshire, following a period of uncertainty for councils and the communities we serve.

“Considerable work has already taken place to prepare for reorganisation, and we will now work alongside our fellow councils to take forward the next stages of this significant change.”

He said the district’s priority had been to keep residents, businesses and communities “at the heart of future arrangements”.

“As we prepare for a new North Oxfordshire Council, it is important that the needs and identities of our market towns, villages and rural communities continue to be recognised and that local people have a strong voice in the decisions that affect them,” he said.

He also said he would be lobbying over the bill. “Having received formal notification of the Government’s decision, I will be making representations to Government to ensure that any potential increase in the cost of delivering services is properly supported and does not fall on our residents.

“Above all, our commitment to West Oxfordshire remains unchanged. We will continue delivering for our district and ensuring the interests of the communities we serve remain central to our work.”

What the Government has proposed

The model is the one Oxford City Council put forward, with the city’s requested boundary changes. West Oxfordshire, together with Cherwell, South Oxfordshire, the Vale of White Horse and West Berkshire, had submitted a rival two-council plan, and Oxfordshire County Council a single county-wide council. The minister’s letter says all three proposals met the Government’s criteria.

Facts panel of the three proposed councils: Northern Oxfordshire Council, all of West Oxfordshire plus Cherwell minus 15 parishes, including Witney, Banbury and Bicester, about 265,000 people; Greater Oxford Council, Oxford plus 41 parishes from Cherwell, South Oxfordshire and the Vale of White Horse, about 241,000; Ridgeway Council, most of South Oxfordshire and the Vale with West Berkshire, about 429,000. Shadow elections May 2028, new councils from 1 April 2029
The three councils in the Government's minded-to decision. Graphic by Witney News.
Share this chartFacebookWhatsAppX

The three councils, with the populations given in the letter:

  • Northern Oxfordshire Council: all of West Oxfordshire and Cherwell, minus 15 Cherwell parishes that move to Greater Oxford. About 265,000 people.
  • Greater Oxford Council: Oxford plus 15 parishes from Cherwell, 17 from South Oxfordshire and nine from the Vale of White Horse. About 241,000.
  • Ridgeway Council: the rest of South Oxfordshire and the Vale, combined with West Berkshire. About 429,000.

None of the 41 parishes listed in the letter’s annex as moving into Greater Oxford is in West Oxfordshire, so the whole district stays together. The nearest change is next door in Cherwell, where Kidlington, Yarnton and Begbroke would go to Greater Oxford.

The letter describes Northern Oxfordshire as an authority built around “established market towns such as Banbury, Bicester and Witney, alongside surrounding rural communities with distinct identities”. It says the plan proposes Neighbourhood Area Committees and keeps town and parish councils, which Northern Oxfordshire “could use” to reflect the different interests of “Banbury, Bicester and Witney and their surrounding areas”. How much power those committees would have is left to be worked out during implementation.

The Government does not hide the weaknesses Cllr Graham points to. All three councils would be below its guiding population of 500,000, which the letter calls “not a fixed threshold”. It says ministers have “lower confidence in the efficiency evidence submitted for the three unitary option due to the scale and timing of savings”, and that the model involves “the most complex implementation requirements”. It concludes that the departmental modelling still shows the three councils could be as financially sustainable as today’s arrangements, or more.

How we got here

This is the second time the Government has chosen this model. It first confirmed three councils on 16 July, to take over on 1 April 2028. On 7 September it paused that decision as part of a national review. Thursday’s letter withdraws the July decision formally and replaces it with a fresh provisional one, saying the earlier decision “is not being treated as determining the outcome”.

Oxfordshire was one of five areas where the Government said it was minded to go ahead, alongside East Sussex, Gloucestershire, Warwickshire and Worcestershire. Decisions for nine other areas were withdrawn the same day.

Oxfordshire County Council is still weighing a legal challenge. The district council’s statement says the county sent a legal letter to the Government earlier this month and issued a protective claim in court over a possible judicial review. The county has been asking for the evidence behind the July decision, and “will now consider any information shared by the government that has informed its new minded-to decision, assess its position and any further appropriate actions”.

The money

Oxfordshire will receive £1.35 million in November, half of the £900,000 per new council the Government offers to cover transition costs, the letter says. The rest, plus £150,000 per new council for leadership in children’s services, adult social care and public health, would follow a final decision.

What it means for you

Nothing changes yet. West Oxfordshire District Council still collects your bins, decides planning applications and bills your council tax, and Oxfordshire County Council still runs the roads, schools and social care.

  • If the decision is confirmed, from 1 April 2029 one council, Northern Oxfordshire, would run all of those services for Witney, Carterton, Chipping Norton, Woodstock, Banbury and Bicester.
  • You would elect its first councillors in May 2028.
  • You can have your say now. The letter invites “relevant councils and other interested parties” to respond in roughly the next three weeks. The councils’ joint site, 3councils.org, lets you check which new council would serve your community.
  • It could still change. The letter says the Secretary of State “remains open to reaching a different conclusion”, including choosing a different proposal or none at all.

We will report the final decision when it is made.

Sources