The government has refused permission for Botley West Solar Farm, the 840MW scheme planned for farmland west of Oxford around Bladon, Church Hanborough, Cassington and Begbroke.

The decision was made on Tuesday, 10 November, by Baroness Curran, a minister in the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero, on behalf of the Secretary of State. It follows an examination by the Planning Inspectorate, whose four inspectors had also recommended refusal.

West Oxfordshire District Council, which objected to the scheme throughout, welcomed the ruling.

Why it was refused

The minister concluded that the harm the solar farm would cause outweighed its benefits. The decision letter sets out the main reasons:

  • substantial harm to the Green Belt
  • harm to listed buildings and other heritage assets, including the setting of the Blenheim Palace World Heritage Site
  • significant harm to the landscape and to views
  • a remaining risk to safety at London Oxford Airport, which the inspectors described as the biggest pilot-training airport in England
  • problems with how the developer assessed and planned to restore the best farmland

The letter names the Grade I churches at Church Hanborough and Cassington and the Grade II* church at Begbroke among the buildings affected. It also points to the Bladon Conservation Area.

On the airport, the inspectors said only the minimum had been done to protect trainee pilots who might need to make an emergency landing after an engine failure on take-off. A bank of panels was still shown in the fields west of the runway.

The government did give the scheme’s contribution to clean energy substantial weight. It still found the overall balance came down against it.

What the council says

The district council took part in the examination as a host authority. It submitted technical evidence and appeared at the Planning Inspectorate hearings. It raised concerns about the landscape and rural character of West Oxfordshire, heritage, wildlife, farmland, transport, footpaths and local communities. Its formal position was that the scheme, as submitted, should not be supported because the harm outweighed the benefits.

Councillor Liz Leffman, the council’s Executive Member for Planning and Infrastructure, said:

“We welcome today’s decision by the Secretary of State following the thorough examination of this proposal.

“Throughout this process, the Council has remained committed to providing a robust, evidence-based representation on behalf of our communities. We have consistently sought to ensure that the likely impacts of this proposal on West Oxfordshire were fully understood and properly considered through the national planning process. We are pleased to see that the Secretary of State and Planning Inspectorate have recognised the concerns that were highlighted though our representations.”

She added that the council supports renewable energy, but not at any cost:

“We have always recognised the important role renewable energy has to play in tackling climate change and achieving net zero. However, we have also maintained that developments of this scale must be planned carefully and must appropriately balance national energy needs with protecting local communities, our countryside, heritage and natural environment.

“I would like to thank everyone who has worked with us and taken the time to engage with this process over the past three years. The contributions made by residents, parish councils, community organisations and our officers have ensured that local knowledge and concerns have been clearly presented throughout the examination.”

How the decision was reached

The application was made by Photovolt Development Partners on behalf of SolarFive Ltd. It covered land in West Oxfordshire, Cherwell and the Vale of White Horse. The scheme would have had its own main substation, six smaller substations and 156 power converter units.

The key dates were:

Stage Date
Application accepted for examination 13 December 2024
Examination opened 14 May 2025
Examination closed 13 November 2025
Inspectors’ report sent to the minister 10 February 2026
Decision deadline first moved to 10 September 2026
Decision deadline moved again to 10 November 2026
Consent refused 10 November 2026

In the months after the examination, the government asked the developer for more information. The developer’s reply proposed a smaller scheme needing at least about 554 hectares of panels, against about 843 hectares before. The decision letter says that left the minister unable to be sure that smaller sites elsewhere had been properly ruled out.

What happens next

The refusal can only be challenged in the courts. Anyone wanting to do so must apply to the Planning Court for a judicial review within six weeks, starting the day after the decision was published.

All the decision papers, including the inspectors’ full report, are on the Planning Inspectorate’s Botley West page. The council’s own page on the scheme, with its consultation responses, is on the West Oxfordshire District Council website.

What it means for you

If you live around Bladon, Church Hanborough, Cassington or Begbroke, the fields around you will not be covered with solar panels under this scheme, unless a court overturns the refusal. For other planning decisions across the district, see our Witney planning news page.

The council’s statement was issued on 10 November 2026. Read it on the council’s newsroom.