West Oxfordshire District Council has refused outline plans for up to 40 homes on a field off Bampton Road in Aston, the village about four miles south of Witney.
The decision was issued on 29 October, under delegated powers, so it did not go to a planning committee. The decision notice gives five reasons for refusal.
The application, 25/01247/OUT, covered 2.89 hectares of farmland south of Kingsway Cottages. It had been with the council since May 2025. Only the access off Bampton Road was to be fixed at this stage; the layout and design would have come later.
Why it was refused
The decision notice lists these reasons:
- The wrong place. The site is outside Aston and “not physically well-related to the village”, so it would push building out into the countryside.
- The conservation area. Homes on the field would “erode the rural and agricultural setting” of the Aston Conservation Area, whose boundary runs along two sides of the site.
- The landscape. Losing the open field would harm the western approach to the village and the edge between Aston and the countryside around it.
- Flooding. The applicant had not shown the homes would be safe from flooding for their lifetime, or would not make flooding worse elsewhere.
- No legal agreement. No Section 106 agreement was signed to secure the affordable homes, school money and other contributions the scheme would have owed.
The planning officer’s delegated report says the fifth reason was added “to protect the Council’s position in the event of an appeal”.
Three flood reports and an Environment Agency objection
Flooding was the longest-running argument on the file.
The western part of the field is in Flood Zone 2, according to the officer’s report. The eastern part has a high chance of surface water flooding.
The Environment Agency first raised concerns in July 2025. By 28 September 2026 it was formally objecting. The report says the agency was still not satisfied that the flood modelling was robust, even after amended modelling and a new flood risk assessment.
The county council, as lead local flood authority, had dropped its own objection in July 2026. Aston, Cote, Shifford and Chimney Parish Council criticised that change, the report records.
The parish council objected three times, in July 2025, November 2025 and July 2026. Each time it sent in more flood evidence, including independently commissioned reviews, challenging the applicant’s figures.
Who else objected
The council received 47 comments from members of the public, all of them opposed, the report says. Concerns included flooding, sewage capacity, traffic, the loss of farmland and pressure on schools and doctors.
Other objections on the file included:
- Bampton Parish Council, which said Bampton Sewage Works was already 27% over capacity, with no confirmed date for an upgrade by Thames Water.
- Windrush Against Sewerage Pollution, which said the works was under “significant pressure” and that building should not go ahead before it was upgraded.
- The district’s conservation officer, who found harm to the setting of the conservation area.
- Oxfordshire County Council’s minerals team, which said the homes would sterilise safeguarded sand and gravel beneath the site.
Thames Water itself did not object, provided upgrades to the sewer network came before anyone moved in.
What the homes would have brought
The report sets out what the scheme offered:
- 40% of the homes as affordable housing, which the officer gave “substantial weight”
- £372,690 for primary and nursery school places and £35,411 for special educational needs, requested by the county council
- £54,560 towards bus services
Officers accepted those benefits were substantial. They concluded they did not “substantially outweigh” the harm.
A housing shortfall in the background
The refusal came despite a district-wide shortage of land for housing.
The report says the council’s latest published housing land supply is 4.3 years, below the five years the government expects. It adds that officers expect the real figure “is likely to fall between 2-3 years”.
That shortfall is why the national rules on housing outside villages applied at all. The report also says recent appeal decisions have established an “acute” need for affordable housing in the district.
What it means for you
If you live in Aston or Bampton, the field off Bampton Road stays as farmland for now.
The applicant can appeal to the Planning Inspectorate. If an appeal is lodged, it will appear on the application’s page, where residents can follow it.
The whole file, including the flood reports and the parish council’s evidence, is public on the council’s planning register.
Have your say